Economy

Surveillance pricing ban passes New York City Council

New York City Council approved a surveillance pricing ban. The bill keeps qualifying discounts and would take effect a year after becoming law.

Two illustrated shoppers reach for identical apples beneath blank price tags and an abstract watching eye.

AI-generated image

New York City Council approved a surveillance pricing ban on November 12, 2026, the council said. Speaker Julie Menin sponsored the bill, which targets prices based on personal data.

The vote was 44 to five, according to City & State. Mayor Zohran Mamdani supports the bill, it reported. But the vote does not put the ban into effect. The bill sets a one-year wait after it becomes law.

What the surveillance pricing ban would cover

Under Introduction 891-A, firms could not use algorithms and personal data to vary prices by customer for the same goods or services. It also bars firms from gathering or sharing data to enable surveillance pricing. An algorithm is a set of rules that software uses to turn data into results.

However, the bill keeps genuine sales and certain loyalty discounts. It also allows stated discounts for groups such as seniors or veterans. Those shoppers must knowingly share their details. These discounts must apply to all shoppers who meet the stated terms.

The text also exempts insurance and prices based on a buyer’s ability to repay credit. The city’s Department of Consumer and Worker Protection would enforce the rules, with civil fines of up to $1,000 per violation. Each affected shopper or sale can count as a separate breach.

Why changing prices are not all the same

AP explains the difference between dynamic and personalized pricing. Dynamic prices respond to market conditions, such as supply and demand. Personalized prices instead draw on data about a shopper, such as income or browsing habits. Thus, a changing price alone does not show that a seller used personal data.

The Federal Trade Commission’s initial surveillance pricing study found that tools can use browsing and shopping habits. Inputs can include mouse movements and goods left in an online cart. The agency studied firms that help retailers set prices and offers.

That work has limits. The FTC said it used hypothetical examples to protect firms’ private business details. The study therefore shows how these tools work. It does not prove that all stores use them. Nor does it show that each price difference stems from a personal profile.

The next step is with the mayor

City & State reported that firms including Uber opposed the bill over concerns about discounts. Menin said the measure would still allow discounts. The surveillance pricing bill sets terms for those discounts rather than banning them all.

As of November 13, the council’s bill record placed it at the mayor’s desk for signing. The council’s guide gives the mayor 30 days once he receives a bill. He can sign, veto or take no action. If he takes no action within that period, a bill becomes law. A veto can face a council override by a two-thirds vote.

Sources: NYC Council bill, NYC Council announcement, FTC, NYC Council legislative process, City & State, AP